Is Amazon Greenwashing?

Amazon, the world’s largest online retailer, has grown rapidly due to its convenience, vast selection, and often low prices. In recent years, the company has also made significant efforts to position itself as a leader in sustainability, announcing initiatives aimed at reducing its carbon footprint and waste. However, given Amazon’s size and the complexity of its operations, many question whether these sustainability efforts are more about marketing than real environmental impact. Let’s explore whether Amazon’s claims hold up or if they fall into the realm of greenwashing. 

What is Greenwashing?

Greenwashing occurs when companies present themselves as environmentally friendly but fail to take meaningful actions that match their claims. In Amazon’s case, this could involve promoting its sustainability initiatives while ignoring or downplaying the environmental impacts of its vast global operations, such as excessive packaging waste and carbon emissions from shipping. Understanding greenwashing is key to determining if Amazon’s sustainability promises are genuine or just a PR move.

Amazon’s Sustainability Goals

Amazon has made a number of bold pledges regarding its environmental efforts. In 2019, the company co-founded The Climate Pledge, which commits to reaching net-zero carbon emissions by 2040—10 years ahead of the Paris Agreement’s goal. They’ve also promised to run 100% of their operations on renewable energy by 2025. Another significant initiative is their pledge to make half of all shipments carbon neutral by 2030, achieved through a combination of sustainable transportation methods and carbon offsetting.

On the surface, these goals appear to reflect a genuine commitment to sustainability. Amazon has already invested in electric delivery vehicles and solar farms and is pushing for more sustainable packaging options, such as the "Frustration-Free Packaging" program, designed to reduce excess waste.

The Positive Moves

Amazon has indeed taken notable steps that deserve recognition:

• Electric Delivery Vehicles: Amazon has ordered 100,000 electric vans from Rivian to reduce emissions from its massive delivery fleet. This is a substantial commitment to greener logistics.
• Renewable Energy Investments: The company is the largest corporate buyer of renewable energy in the world. Their investments in wind and solar projects across the globe aim to meet their ambitious goal of operating entirely on renewable energy by 2025.
• Sustainable Packaging: Amazon’s Frustration-Free Packaging program has reduced the use of plastic and excessive packaging materials. The program encourages suppliers to use more sustainable and recyclable packaging options.

These initiatives show that Amazon is taking concrete steps toward sustainability. However, are these moves enough to offset the enormous environmental costs of operating one of the largest e-commerce companies in the world?

The Contradictions and Concerns

Despite these positive efforts, there are significant concerns about Amazon's true environmental impact:

• Excessive Packaging Waste: Despite the Frustration-Free Packaging program, Amazon continues to be criticized for excessive packaging. Many customers report receiving small items in oversized boxes filled with plastic packaging, which contradicts their "zero waste" philosophy. With millions of packages shipped daily, the amount of waste generated is staggering.
• Carbon Emissions from Shipping: While Amazon has pledged to reduce its carbon footprint, the company’s business model is based on rapid, global shipping. This reliance on air freight and last-mile delivery services contributes heavily to carbon emissions, especially with the increase in next-day and same-day delivery services. Even with electric vehicles and carbon offset programs, the overall environmental impact of their logistics network is significant.
• Labor and Sustainability: Sustainability isn’t just about environmental impact; it also encompasses ethical labor practices. Amazon has faced significant criticism for working conditions in its warehouses and the environmental justice implications of building fulfillment centers in low-income areas. These issues raise questions about whether Amazon's approach to sustainability is truly holistic or simply focused on certain environmental metrics.

Greenwashing or Greenwishing?

Given Amazon’s massive scale and its business model centered on fast delivery and consumerism, it’s difficult to see the company as genuinely eco-friendly. While Amazon has made strides in sustainable practices, its continued reliance on fossil-fueled transportation, excessive packaging, and controversial labor practices paint a complex picture. Their ambitious environmental goals sometimes feel more like "greenwishing"—making big promises for the future—without fully addressing the contradictions in their current practices.

Despite these efforts, Amazon’s sheer scale and environmental contradictions mean it still has a long way to go before it can be considered truly sustainable. The company’s heavy reliance on air freight and other high-emission transportation methods, combined with its wasteful packaging practices, suggest that it has a lot more work to do before its environmental impact aligns with its promises.

So, Is Amazon Greenwashing, Greenwishing, or Greenhushing?

Amazon’s approach to sustainability appears to be a blend of greenwashing, greenwishing, and greenhushing. The company has made notable investments in renewable energy and sustainable packaging, but its massive scale and ongoing environmental challenges indicate elements of greenwashing, where its sustainability messaging does not fully match its practices. With ambitious long-term goals, Amazon seems to also embody greenwishing—aspiring to be more sustainable without making enough immediate changes. Additionally, Amazon tends to avoid fully addressing the environmental toll of its rapid delivery model, suggesting an element of greenhushing, where certain impacts are minimized or left out of the conversation. To move beyond these labels, Amazon must demonstrate measurable, meaningful progress in reducing its overall environmental footprint.

Wait, Doesn't Marley's Monsters Sell on Amazon?

Yes, Marley's Monsters does sell products through Amazon, and we understand this might seem contradictory given the concerns around Amazon's environmental impact. However, our decision to partner with Amazon is based on the desire to make eco-friendly, reusable products available to a wider audience. We believe that by offering sustainable alternatives on such a large platform, we can help reduce overall waste by reaching more people who might not otherwise have access to our products.

This partnership allows us to scale our mission, ensuring that even in a marketplace like Amazon, there are options for consumers who prioritize sustainability. At the same time, we continue to maintain our own strict eco-friendly practices—from using recycled materials to minimizing packaging—regardless of the platform through which our products are sold. For us, the choice is clear: it's better to be part of the solution, offering greener alternatives, than to remain limited in our reach.

Ultimately, we see this as an opportunity to make a positive impact at a larger scale while staying true to our values. One day, we hope to be large enough to effect change on groups such as Amazon! You can help us on our journey by swapping to eco-friendly products, such as those that we sell. Want to make sure it’s as eco-friendly as possible? You can cut out Amazon and buy directly from our online store, ensuring a better and more sustainable experience for all.

Sources: